Earlier today, there was a fascinating discussion that started with Dean’s mention of Bill Cosby’s rant about the gangsta culture thing going on in the black community. Dean also pointed out that there’s a sizeable lowerclass that’s white, too.
I’ve been thinking about it all day. Took it to work with me, and now here I sit and it’s almost midnight here in AZ.
At Dean’s World, they pretty much settled on the idea that it’s not actually a race issue, but an economic one. The are lots of reasons we have this group of poor, undereducated, and socially bereft people, but to boil down to the simplest level, I’d say that it’s partly the situation of the poor always being with us, (which turns out to be a biblical quote, to my surprise) and partly the result of welfare programs dating back to the Depression era.
So that’s 60 years, give or take, that this burgeoning lower class has been developing. That’s several generations. It took a long time for ignorance and poverty to become “cool.”
I took Dean’s advice and ordered a book he thought was important to this discussion – and I’m wondering what it’s going to be like.
A few months ago, I read Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America and was appalled at how patronizing and insulting it was to the people Barbara Ehrenreich wrote about. In true Marxist fashion, her solution to the “plight” of this group was more money from the government. She made the mistake of presuming the group of people she saw was representative of everybody working in minimum-wage jobs, and made some sweeping generalizations that ultimately made not much sense.
I’m hoping this other one will be a bit more rational.
Right now, I’m thinking two things:
1. There are people who will not be helped, no matter what you do.
2. If there is one thing that is shared in common by everyone in this lower class, it seems to me that it’s a sense of being disconnected from the community.
So the thing to work on would be the second thing. I wonder though, if it might not take an equally long time to correct the errors of the past. Almost one person at a time.
I don’t know. Stay tuned.