Feminist author Naomi Wolf was on FoxNews earlier this AM lamenting the existence of books such as this one, which is an example of a new genre of raunchy material featuring graphic sex and drug use marketed to kids.
However, she went far of the mark in her suggestions on what to do about it. As you’d expect, she immediately absolved parents of any responsibility in this matter. As she said, “I wouldn’t have read any of these myself if I hadn’t had to review them.” Further, she claimed that parents can’t read everything their kids bring home.
Her solution? The government, of course, along with bookstores and libraries. “They should be the gatekeepers,” she said.
I have to say how sorry I feel for her kids, to have a mother who is so self-absorbed she won’t take any time to review what her kids are reading. What a wonderful opportunity they are all missing! Sharing books with your kids at any age is an experience not to be duplicated.
Naomi’s admitted neglect of her children’s reading aside, what she proposes is as impossible as it is outrageous. In the first place, no outside entity, be it government, bookseller or library can possibly know what any given family’s standards are on books.
These books most likely won’t end up on many library’s shelves in any case, because they are (as far as I can tell) paperback, and libraries tend not to buy those, due to their insubstantial construction. Some frequently-requested paperbacks are re-bound for library use, but most often they are relegated to a “trade one-for-one” rack, if they have them at all.
Suggesting the government be responsible is also ridiculous, since that kind of involvement in publishing is usually spelled C-E-N-S-O-R-S-H-I-P.
How booksellers choose to deal with this issue is entirely up to the individual company.
The only realistic way to approach this is by the parents taking the responsibility for what their children read. It cannot be left up to “the village,” as that is simply not feasible.
Or was she intending to suggest that some books be banned?