Lisa Williams’ blog appears to be down, so I’ve taken the liberty of copying the whole post from my aggregator ( the blessing of RSS!) but the post does illustrate a couple of things. So here it is:
I’m sitting in a cafe. At the next table are a man and a woman, former work colleagues who ran into one another. While catching up, the woman says that she’s entered film school. The man says something inaudible, to which she replies:
“I’ll be a citizen, sure, but I’ll never be an American.”
I found myself surprisingly offended by this comment. Like so many people who want to immigrate to the US, she wants what the US has to offer, but she doesn’t want to be an American?
After a few minutes I realize it could be interpreted other ways: maybe she feels excluded by American society, that she feels she’ll never be a “real” American. Or that she doesn’t want to give up her ethnic identity, or be associated with negative stereotypes of Americans.I don’t know.
What Lisa is catching on to, and that most pundits and commentators seem to have missed, is the fact there is a large, and growing number of immigrants, both legal and not, who have no intention of ever “assimilating” as Americans.
In border communities such as Yuma, and places such as New York or Los Angeles, there is no need for Hispanic immigrants to learn English, nor is there any need for citizenship.
All the social services, and even many churches conduct their business in Spanish. There is TV, newspapers, and radio in Spanish, and the schools bend over backward to accommodate Spanish-speaking students at all levels, from kindergarten to college.
Unless you intend to retire and/or run for public office in the US, the benefits to citizenship aren’t all that compelling either, considering the mindset of this new wave of immigrants. Many of these people already send money home, and are perhaps likely to return to their home country for their retirement, where they can live comfortably on less than they can here.
It is entirely possible to live and work in the United States for years without becoming a citizen, and then simply go home once the economic benefits of being here are exhausted. That’s the scary part. What happens if Congress makes it easier to do this?
What happens to American culture?
Update: Poll: Immigration Worries Growing in U.S. (story at WaPo)