There’s a brisk discussion going on at Dean’s World on bookstores and boycotts.
Andrew Cory says, in part:
See, a bookstore’s only stocking priority ought to be “will it sell”. Once the commercial judgment is replaced with editorial one, a company sets itself up as a censor. It begins to limit access to knowledge, and democracy itself is tarnished...
Ron Coleman started it with:
I'm open to persuasion on this. I realize this position represents a moral compromise. But my guess is that people who own businesses and homes, who have families and friends in the real and vulnerable world, will recognize that you have to pick your battles. Waldenbooks and Borders are only book stores. I don't expect the Department of State to be so cautious. But how many armored divisions does Borders have?
Andrew and Ron both have valid points. Is the refusal by Borders and Waldenbooks to stock a certain issue of a magazine due to its inflammatory nature which could possibly lead to trouble in their stores censorship? Or is it simple pragmatism, with its roots in concern for their property and the safety of everyone concerned?
At our library, we have Mein Kampf. I figure the Marine Corps believes it’s important for this work to be read and understood in its own context, though there are many other works to provide other viewpoints. (Yes, it is being read from time to time.)
We also have Twentynine Palms, a piece of anti-male, anti-military crap that is offensive to our clientele in general, and only notable for its many factual errors and clear illustration that the author had no clue what she was talking about.
But a library, especially a military library, has a lot of subjective reasons for making a book or periodical available or not. A library is not a bookstore. In this case, the discussion isn’t pertinent because the magazine in question isn’t something we subscribe to in the first place.
In the end, I guess it all boils down to this: it’s really not our business to tell anyone how to run their business. After all, they’re not keeping anybody from getting the magazine. I’d bet they’d be willing to tell you how to get it direct from the publisher.